The Finance – State – Society Triangle in Europe

The past and the next forty years

International Conference at the Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam

Date: 23 January 2018
10:00-17:00h, Amsterdam, Vrije Universiteit
more information pending

Theme | Program →

About the theme

The financial crisis was not caused by the financial sector alone. This crisis, or rather our current situation, is the outcome of a process that was fuelled also by the state and by society as a whole. The origins of this process lie far back in time, yet it is evident that the process accelerated some forty years ago. If we restrict our history of the present to those forty years, it can indeed be ascertained that the relationships in the finance - state - society triangle have been altered drastically over this period of time. All three actors have changed and they have changed each other, in one single and ongoing process of complex transformation. The one concept to label this transformation is financialization. This process in turn is deeply connected to other far-reaching and accelerating changes, such as globalization, digitalization, virtualization and robotization.

Analyses of the financial crisis have commonly identified the practices of the financial sector as its main cause; and it is indeed an undeniable fact that much has gone wrong here. Following these analyses, strong disciplinary measures were enforced to keep the sector in check; and these interventions surely have had beneficial effects on the sectors’ health. However, this policy has now reached its limits and has come to generate adverse results for both the sector itself and the society that it serves. After all, society now has to cope with a handicapped service provider when it comes to financial issues.

Furthermore, the actual root causes of the financial crisis have not been addressed by those policies. If we agree that our current situation is the outcome of one single process in which the financial sector, the state and society all played their part and in which they themselves and their relationships were transformed; and if we agree that this outcome is undesirable because full of economic and societal risks for the future;

» then we must also agree that a possible way out can only be explored when based on a shared analysis and understanding of our common history of the present and on a shared commitment to making an effort to reorient the process in the desired direction. This should and can only be a shared effort of the financial sector, state and society.

Working hypothesis for the international conference

The question that will guide the international conference is:

» is it useful (deemed possible, realistic, feasible) to explore the perspectives for a proper European arrangement between the financial sector, state and society?

A proper European arrangement, both referring to its origin and features, and in the sense of distinct and relatively autonomous from the present, financialized and Anglo-America dominated global arrangement.

In the run-up to this conference, two high level seminars were held in The Netherlands, in January and in June this year, with speakers and participants form the financial sector, politics, business, academy and civil society. The seminars were chaired by former Dutch Prime Minister prof. Jan Peter Balkenende and prof. Hans Schenk, Crown member of the Dutch Social and Economic Council. One point of reference for the seminars was the excellent report Balancing society and the financial sector by the Dutch Scientific Council for Government Policy, expounded by its main author, prof. Arnoud Boot.

Both seminars, under Chatham House rule, addressed the following three questions:

- How have we – financial sector, government, academy, companies and households; in short, our society – come to the current situation? i.e. reviewing our history of the present.

- How do we assess our current situation with a view to the future, in its structural, societal, cultural and ethical dimensions?

- Can this ongoing process be reoriented?

The main recommendation that came out of these seminars was that the experience should be repeated at an international level, involving representatives from relevant like-minded countries such as Germany, Belgium, Luxemburg, France and Austria. These countries were selected because supposedly they share a Rhenish legacy – though it should be stressed that this conference is not about restoring it!

Thus, the conference will address the triplet: history of the present - our current situation - possible reorientation with a view to establish the usefulness of exploring the perspectives for a proper European arrangement between the financial sector, state and society. Not less, and not more. It is expressly not the idea to come up with solutions or to design possible new arrangements. Solutions, new arrangements or institutions can only be viable if they are the outcome of a process in which the concerned parties willingly agree to give up part of their autonomy for a collective effort for a shared purpose, i.e. based on trust – and that is precisely where financialization comes in the way.

The outcome of the January conference and the follow-up seminar

As the nature of the conference is an open conversation on the usefulness of exploring the idea of a proper European financio-societal arrangement, its outcome cannot be predicted.

Ideally, the outcome of the conference is that all (foreign) participants agree that indeed it is useful to further explore this idea, and even agree to engage and to commit themselves to at least two next steps: 1. to further the process in their home-country and 2. to participate in the follow-up international conference, to be held in 2018, in Amsterdam or elsewhere.

In this ideal case, the seminar following the conference (on 24 January, 9.00-13.00 hrs), will be geared towards the preparation of these next steps, establishing themes to be developed, priorities, responsibilities, timelines and so, both at the national and the supra-national level; depending of course on the material that comes out of the conference. Eventually, national working groups may be established and representatives designated.

In the less-than-ideal case, the seminar on 24 January will be used to deepen the conversation held on the conference, with a view also to reinforce the academic and policy relevance of the conference report that will be published by Amsterdam University Press.


Around Ethics & Finance

8 Dec 2017 |
Inequality and the Coming Storm
In recent decades, the wealth gap between a narrow upper class and the rest of the human population has become a gaping chasm, with far-reaching impli ...

8 Dec 2017 |
The High Cost of Denying Class War
The rise of populism on both sides of the Atlantic is being investigated psychoanalytically, culturally, anthropologically, aesthetically, and of cour ...

28 Nov 2017 |
The Global Economy in 2018
The global economy will confront serious challenges in the months and years ahead, and looming in the background is a mountain of debt that makes mark ...

12 Nov 2017 | Hans Ariens
Ben je aandeelhouder of mens?
Op bezoek naar andere businessmodellen op Nationaal Sustainability Congres Kan dat, zo veel mogelijk olie, gas, of mobiele telefoons verkopen, en tege ...

7 Nov 2017 | Ricardo Hausmann
The Moral Identity of Homo Economicus
Two recent books indicate that a quiet revolution is challenging the foundations of the dismal science, promising radical changes in how we view many ...

[> all messages

News from our partners

Moral Markets

11 Dec 2017 | Forget Mark Zuckerberg’s Charity – We Need Corporate Tax Reform

8 Dec 2017 | Wall Street at 30: is Greed Still Good?

Konrad Adenauer Stiftung

6 Dec 2017 | Europäische Nachbarschaftspolitik: GIPFEL DER ÖSTLICHEN PARTNERSCHAFT IN BRÜSSEL

17 Nov 2017 | Der Kampf gegen terroristische Inhalte: Experten Austausch mit Kent Walker


29 Nov 2017 | Moody’s affirms ratings Rabobank

24 Nov 2017 | Fitch affirms Rabobank at ‘AA-‘; Outlook Stable

Centrum Èthos

17 Nov 2017 | Kom kijken bij de masteravond FCB op de VU!

10 Nov 2017 | Ad Verbrugge te gast in Kwartslag